Trump Lawyer Claims in Federal Court That the President Can, in Fact, Shoot Someone on Fifth Avenue and Not Be Charged

US President Donald Trump speaks during a Memorial Day event aboard the amphibious assault ship USS Wasp (LHD 1) in Yokosuka on May 28, 2019. (Photo by Brendan SMIALOWSKI / AFP) (Photo credit should read BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images)

While much of the nation was preoccupied with a cabal of House Republicans throwing a tantrum that threatened national security, President Donald Trump's lawyers argued in front of a Federal Appeals Court that Manhattan prosecutors had no right to subpoena Trump's personal and corporate tax returns.

The lawyers' argument strikes to the heart of the current Justice Department policy—enforced by Attorney General William Barr—that a sitting president can't be indicted and, therefore, is also immune to criminal investigation.


Trump's lawyers were appealing a lower court ruling which described the defense as "repugnant to the nation’s governmental structure and constitutional values."

During the 2016 campaign, Trump famously bragged that he could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and not lose any supporters. Carey Dunne, Counsel for the Manhattan District Attorney, invoked Trump's claim as an example of the ridiculousness of the argument that the President is immune from criminal investigation.

Judge Denny Chin asked Trump lawyer William S. Consovoy if he was arguing that "nothing could be done" if the President actually did shoot someone on Fifth Avenue.

Consovoy argued that, even then, Trump would be immune from investigation.

Listen below:

Judge Denny Chin asked Consovoy if his position was that nothing could be done if the President shot someone on Fifth Avenue.

Consovoy responded:

"That is correct."

The case is being argued in front of a federal appeals court—just one level below the Supreme Court. Its chief judge, Robert A. Katzmann said:

"This case seems bound for the Supreme Court. We have the feeling that you may be seeing each other again in Washington."

Two Justices on the Supreme Court were picked by Trump—it's unclear whether or not they would recuse themselves if the case were to ascend to the nation's highest court.

People balked that it had actually come to this: A lawyer arguing in a court of law that Trump would have immunity if he shot someone on Fifth Avenue.

It's unclear when the panel will issue its ruling.

CNN video/Win McNamee/Getty Images

Maine's Democratic primary is slated for March 3.

The vote will determine who faces off against incumbent Republican Susan Collins in November.

Keep reading...
ABC/The View

President Donald Trump has made no effort to keep his thoughts on the trial of his former advisor, Roger Stone, a secret.

Stone was convicted of lying to Congress, obstructing justice, and threatening a witness last year. When prosecutors recommended a seven to nine year prison sentence, Trump fumed on Twitter and the Justice Department subsequently overrode the opinion of its prosecutors, who resigned in response.

Today, Stone was sentenced to 40 months in prison for his crimes, leading everyone to ask: Will Trump pardon one of his most vocal allies?

Keep reading...
Chris Graythen/Getty Images // Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

With 2.4 billion active users, Facebook has become a breeding ground for disinformation. Misleading or outright false allegations played an unignorable part of the assault on the 2016 election and a number of lawmakers say Facebook isn't doing enough to curtail fake news ahead of 2020.

Now a recent Washington Post report detailing Facebook's response to fake news pages after President Donald Trump's shocking victory in 2016 is raising even more concerns.

Keep reading...
Mark Wilson/Getty Images

Republicans often claim their party has the upper hand with voters when it comes to fiscal responsibility. When a Democrat is in office, one of the chief complaints you can count on from Republican lawmakers is that the President is ballooning the deficit, or sending the federal debt skyward.

This hasn't quite been the case when it's a Republican President occupying the White House.

Keep reading...
NBC News

Contenders for the 2020 Democratic nomination debated in Las Vegas, Nevada on Tuesday ahead of the state's primary in the most confrontational debate yet.

Present on the debate stage for the first time was billionaire former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, a late entry to the campaign whose advertising blitz helped contribute to his rise in the polls, despite having yet to appear on a primary ballot.

Keep reading...
Leon Neal/Getty Images

President Donald Trump's constant trips to his own golf properties around the globe has been a matter of some controversy since he took office in 2017.

A constant critic of President Barack Obama's golf outings—which unlike Trump Obama did not personally profit from—the 45th POTUS claimed he would be too busy working to ever play golf.

Keep reading...