White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders is under scrutiny after she claimed that the media is at fault for thwarting U.S. spying on Osama bin Laden's activities prior to the 9/11 terrorist attacks.
Sanders said the following as she answered a question about threats and insults reporters have faced from Trump supporters:
When it comes to the media the president does think that the media holds a responsibility. We fully support a free press, but there also comes a high level of responsibility with that. The media routinely reports on classified information and government secrets that put lives in danger and risks valuable national security tools. One of the worst cases was the reporting on the U.S. ability to listen to Osama Bin Laden's satellite phone in the late 90s. Because of that reporting, he stopped using that phone and the country lost valuable intelligence.
Sec. Sanders: "The media routinely reports on classified information and government secrets...One of the worst case… https://t.co/qO1v37yLb9— NBC News (@NBC News)1533176100.0
That story has been debunked––and CNN soon called Sanders out.
White House press secretary Sarah Sanders falsely blamed journalists for thwarting US spying on Osama bin Laden jus… https://t.co/P1neYHn73u— CNN (@CNN)1533163268.0
As CNN's Jeremy Diamond notes in the piece:
That assertion is false and has previously been debunked years ago.
Sanders did not respond to CNN requests asking which article she was specifically referring to, but Sanders appeared to be drawing on a claim by former President George W. Bush and the 9/11 Commission.
Bush and the commission in 2005 blamed an August 1998 article in The Washington Times for revealing that the US government had the ability to monitor bin Laden's satellite communications.
The story in question did not claim that the US government was monitoring the phone, instead merely reporting that bin Laden used a satellite phone––something that was widely known at the time. Further, a Washington Post article from the time of Bush's accusation points out that the Taliban, and bin Laden himself, not the US government, were the sources of information about bin Laden's phone usage.
Several media reports, including one from CNN, around the time of the August 1998 Washington Times story also noted that bin Laden used a satellite phone, including to conduct media interviews. Only a USA Today story from around that time quoted a former US official noting that bin Laden "had a fondness for his cell phone."
Diamond goes on to note that:
Despite the lack of reporting about the US government monitoring that phone, some national security officials at the time later claimed bin Laden's [sic] stopped using that satellite phone because of the Washington Times report––and the 9/11 commission later parroted that assertion.
On September 7, 1998 a US newspaper, the Los Angeles Times, reported on US government monitoring of bin Laden's satellite phone––but in that same article they noted that bin Laden could be scaling back use of the devices.
Sanders, for her part, finally responded to CNN, and she stuck to her claims despite being debunked.
.@CNN was NYT “falsely” reporting Lee Hamilton of 9/11 Commission when he said "Leaks can be terribly damaging. In… https://t.co/AmPQWWX8wj— Stephanie Grisham (@Stephanie Grisham)1533174644.0
The message prompted MSNBC's Chris Hayes to ask what Sanders's assertions "have to do with yelling and cursing at a reporter doing a stand up."
@PressSec @CNN What does any of that have to do with yelling and cursing at a reporter doing a stand up?— Chris Hayes (@Chris Hayes)1533174789.0
Morning Joe co-host Joe Scarborough also criticized Sanders, saying that she lied and spread “Pizzagate nonsense."
“But then speaking of fake news, you have Sarah Huckabee Sanders pushing a lie,” Scarborough said. “The fake news about some report on Osama bin Laden and how the press actually stopped American military men and women from catching [bin Laden]. She might as well have said Neil Armstrong never walked on the moon. Just pure conspiracy, ‘Pizzagate’ nonsense.”
Co-host Willie Geist concurred, saying the White House is actively “promoting” conspiracy theories and condemning the presence of apparent QAnon believers––those who believe Robert Mueller was actually appointed by President Donald Trump to investigate Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, and other top Democrats––at one of the president's rallies.
Oh look, QAnon sign at the Trump rally https://t.co/2BwYWMJtWS— Salvador Hernandez (@Salvador Hernandez)1533078807.0
"Widely debunked theory that goes back to his rally two nights ago,” Geist said. “Those QAnon we talked about this yesterday. The signs up everywhere. There’s conspiracy theories all over the place. Not only are they not squashing them, but they’re promoting them from the lectern of the briefing room.”