The Attorneys General (AG) of Washington D.C. and Maryland filed suit against President Donald Trump for violations of the U.S. Constitution’s Emoluments Clause. Now, despite efforts on behalf of the president to have the suit dismissed, a judge ruled their lawsuit will proceed.
No Title of Nobility shall be granted by the United States: And no Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them, shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State.” U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 9, Clause 8
However, Judge Peter Messitte of the US District Court of Maryland restricted the scope of the case to the jurisdictions of the AGs involved in the lawsuit. This includes any Trump Organization holdings in Washington D.C. or Maryland, but excludes others such as Mar-a-Lago in Florida.
— James F. Haning II (@jameshaning) March 23, 2018
BREAKING: A federal judge has denied Trump’s motion to dismiss our emoluments lawsuit, finding that the plaintiffs—DC & Maryland—have standing! The case was brought by the Attorneys General of DC and Maryland, and we have the honor of serving as their co-counsel. #Emoluments pic.twitter.com/vgRto7Xrs5
— Jon Taylor (@jontaylor1) March 28, 2018
Because of this limitation, the president’s involvement with the Trump International Hotel in Washington D.C. will be the focus of the case. Specifically, the AGs allege other businesses suffered as a result of the foreign traffic to the Trump Hotel.
In his 47 page ruling, Judge Messitte wrote,
Their allegation is bolstered by explicit statements from certain foreign government officials indicating that they are clearly choosing to stay at the president’s hotel because, as one representative of a foreign government has stated, they want him to know ‘I love your new hotel’.”
“[A] large number of Maryland and District of Columbia residents are being affected and will continue to be affected when foreign and state governments choose to stay, host events, or dine at the Hotel rather than at comparable Maryland or District of Columbia establishments, in whole or in substantial part simply because of the President’s association with it.”
In December, a federal judge in New York dismissed two other emoluments suits due to lack of standing.
“This is a major step forward for the emoluments litigation,” said Norman Eisen, chairman of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW). Eisen, a former chief ethics lawyer for the Obama administration, added the decision opens the door for suits by other states and businesses near Trump Organization properties.
CREW, a government ethics watchdog group, joined the lawsuit filed by the attorneys general.
Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh stated “we won the first round. It’s a very clear decision that Donald Trump is not above the law and has to be held accountable to the emoluments clause.”
Stay tuned—more to come.
— AG Karl A. Racine (@AGKarlRacine) March 28, 2018
White House spokeswoman Sarah Huckabee Sanders declined to address the ruling during an afternoon press briefing, saying “I can’t comment on pending litigation.”
Plenty of others, however, did comment on the lawsuit and the ruling.
Victory: A federal judge said Wednesday that a lawsuit alleging gifts or payments from foreign and domestic governments made to President Donald Trump may be illegal can proceed. https://t.co/b7E0gm00CK
— Citizens for Ethics (@CREWcrew) March 28, 2018
Funny how only certain parts of the Constitution seem to matter to Trumpers. I’ve always said, it was the emolument violations that would be @potus Achilles heel. Capone was snagged for simple tax evasion.
— Adan Garcia (@Culalam) March 28, 2018
— Jonathan O’Connell (@OConnellPostbiz) March 28, 2018
— Sherry Mason (@masonsherry) March 28, 2018
Meanwhile down at the Hotel Emolumentum….
— Richard W. Painter (@RWPUSA) March 28, 2018
Court says emolument case can go forward. You get a Trump tax return, and you get a Trump tax return. Everyone gets a Trump tax return https://t.co/jb6lOy7BaW
— Broward Gator (@BrowardGator) March 28, 2018
There’s rarely been a more flagrant violation of the Constitution that Trump’s decimation of the Emolument’s Clause, also know as his 118th biggest scandal. https://t.co/ncFPVMrq0z
— LOLGOP (@LOLGOP) March 28, 2018