Teen climate activist Greta Thunberg—visiting the United States from her native Sweden to attend the United Nations Climate Action Summit beginning Monday in New York—spoke during a hearing of the House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis in Washington DC.
In an attempt to justify inaction on climate change through pointing fingers at countries that pollute more, Louisiana Republican Representative Garret Graves tried to make the point that inaction by one justifies inaction by all who pollute as long as they pollute "less."
"I think that what we need to be doing is we need to be focusing on the countries that are dumping trash in the ocean—of course that’s a metaphor."
"Here we are talking about reducing emissions, yet, China under the Paris accords are going to be increasing their emissions by nearly 50 percent—5 gigatons annually."
But Thunberg had facts and a better understanding of perspective for Representative Graves.
"Just another perspective—I’m from Sweden. It’s a small country. And there, it is the same argument. ‘Why should we do anything? Just look at the U.S.,’ they say."
"So, just so you know, that is being used against you as well."
So Graves decided to rephrase his argument framed in a metaphor about sailing across the ocean, picking up trash while the boat next to you dumps trash in the ocean.
"If you were sailing across the ocean and you’re picking up trash along the way, and for every piece of trash you pick up there is a boat right next to you dumping out five pieces. How would that make you feel?"
However Thunberg first corrected the GOP House member's inaccurate analogy by stating the United States may pollute less—according to Republican talking points—but they are not just "picking up trash" while not also dumping some of their own.
“Well, first of all, by that logic then I am also dumping a lot of trash in the ocean. And then I would stop dumping my trash in the ocean and ask the other boat to stop dumping their trash in the ocean as well."
Watch the exchange here.
And here's Greta Thunberg subtly refuting @RepGarretGraves's self-defeating logic that the US doesn't need to do mo… https://t.co/9uysneldAD— Aaron Rupar (@Aaron Rupar)1568820654.0
Seattle, Washington's Jamie Margolin—a 17-year-old climate activist—characterized Graves’ and the GOP's thinking less charitably.
"When your children ask you, 'Did you do absolutely everything in your power to stop the climate crisis?' can you really look them in the eye and say, 'No, sorry, I couldn’t do anything because that country over there didn’t do anything. So if they’re not going to do anything then I’m not'."
"That is shameful. And that is cowardly."
@Jamie_Margolin asks the council members directly: “When your children ask you: Did you do absolutely everything i… https://t.co/Wxjj7xqJqo— Michael Flammer 💚🌍🌡 (@Michael Flammer 💚🌍🌡)1568837456.0
.@Jamie_Margolin calls out climate deniers in congress for putting their wallets over of their children. "They'll… https://t.co/VHqFY2Q2kH— People for Bernie (@People for Bernie)1568819063.0
This is @Jamie_Margolin with one of her many great statements today: "Right now it’s like members of government an… https://t.co/7U0kC6AWdc— Michael Flammer 💚🌍🌡 (@Michael Flammer 💚🌍🌡)1568835875.0
Thunberg began her testimony stating she did not plan to say much because she wanted lawmakers to listen to the scientists then to take action.
.@GretaThunberg: "I have not come to offer any prepared remarks ... I am instead attaching my testimony. It is the… https://t.co/43aBQYyDjK— Aaron Rupar (@Aaron Rupar)1568817916.0
"I want you to unite behind science. And then I want you to take real action." Greta Thunberg and other climate ac… https://t.co/aEXVHVBZTD— AJ+ (@AJ+)1568817683.0
Not every member of the committee understood why listening to the scientists was important.
You can literally see how @GretaThunberg can’t understand how the chairman of the committee on climate change can a… https://t.co/Fete1bUnwI— Michael Flammer 💚🌍🌡 (@Michael Flammer 💚🌍🌡)1568835557.0
@Jumpsteady @GretaThunberg You adults are embarrassing yourselves— chantal de pierres (@chantal de pierres)1568836914.0
@Jumpsteady @GretaThunberg Im glad he didn’t ask who is science ? 😂🙄— SHE (is the ONE) (@SHE (is the ONE))1568837261.0
@Jumpsteady @GretaThunberg "... we slide, almost without noticing, back into superstition and darkness" —Carl Sagan— David Windt (@David Windt)1568835664.0
The day included congressional testimony by several young people.
Activist Vic Barrett spoke to Congress about climate change and reminded lawmakers that those on the frontlines "ar… https://t.co/VMj5TFyHpj— AJ+ (@AJ+)1568818291.0
Youth climate activist Jamie Margolin tells lawmakers: "It doesn't matter how many dreams we have. The reality is… https://t.co/eUKoSaFSMr— AJ+ (@AJ+)1568818492.0
.@Jamie_Margolin told Congress about Indigenous activists in the Amazon who are putting their "bodies on the line"… https://t.co/KXUKiysLGY— AJ+ (@AJ+)1568820265.0
@Jamie_Margolin "I have met people whose neighborhoods were simply destroyed by natural disasters, who were amplifi… https://t.co/oKYQugm2mG— AJ+ (@AJ+)1568820549.0
Listen to the first four episodes of George Takei's podcast, 'Oh Myyy Pod!' where we explore the racially charged videos that have taken the internet by storm.
Be sure to subscribe here and never miss an episode.