53 percent of U.S. voters disapprove of the controversial Republican tax plan, according to a new Quinnipiac University poll released yesterday. 64 percent believe that if passed, the tax plan would benefit only the nation's wealthiest citizens, while only 24 percent think the middle class would benefit. Just 5 percent believe the plan would benefit those in the lowest income bracket. Those who identified as Republicans––67 percent––vastly approved of the legislation; they are the only demographic along party, race, gender, education or age lines to approve.
Yesterday, President Donald Trump took the opportunity to praise the legislation during a lunch with Senate Republicans at the White House to discuss the tax bill, which recently passed the Senate. "It's a fantastic bill for the middle class," the president said. "I view it as a tremendous bill for jobs and the middle class."
The results of the Quinnipiac poll, however, indicate the opposite: 61 percent of voters surveyed believe the tax plan "favors the rich at the expense of the middle class." As if to indicate the harsh divide over the legislation, the plan "will increase their taxes, 41 percent of voters say, while 20 percent say the plan will reduce their taxes and 32 percent say the plan will not have much impact on their taxes."
Despite this, the president has continued to advocate for the measure, as evidenced by many of his recent tweets.
A vote to CUT TAXES is a vote to PUT AMERICA FIRST. It is time to take care of OUR WORKERS, to protect OUR COMMUNIT… https://t.co/WerIo83AE6— Donald J. Trump (@Donald J. Trump)1511998167.0
Now, we have a once in a lifetime opportunity to RESTORE AMERICAN PROSPERITY – and RECLAIM AMERICA’S DESTINY. But… https://t.co/HNvPxZHEIz— Donald J. Trump (@Donald J. Trump)1512002459.0
Trump has also claimed that “the only people” who don’t care for the tax proposal are those who “don’t understand” it and the “Obstructionist Democrats," a sign that he would likely choose to discredit the results of the Quinnipiac poll.
The only people who don’t like the Tax Cut Bill are the people that don’t understand it or the Obstructionist Democ… https://t.co/Kr5HJ8OLCQ— Donald J. Trump (@Donald J. Trump)1512004182.0
The president's approval rating––already low to begin with––also continues to dip, with 47 percent saying that Democrats would do a better job of handling a tax overhaul (and 55 percent expressing similar opinions in regard to health care legislation):
American voters give President Donald Trump a negative 35 - 58 percent job approval rating, compared to 38 - 55 percent in a November 21 Quinnipiac University poll.
Voters say 56 - 40 percent that Trump is not fit to be president, tying his all-time low score.
"Deeply unpopular and manifestly unfit for the job. That's the harsh assessment of President Donald Trump, whose tax plan is considered built for the rich at the expense of the rest," said Tim Malloy, assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Poll.
Senate Republicans have slammed the results of recent polls, insisting they've been "distorted."
Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (
Moore Capito, much like the president, has continued to advocate for the tax bill despite its rampant unpopularity.
Want to know how #taxreform will help you? All of the details are in my newsletter here: https://t.co/D9BLnRdY5b https://t.co/N7igZFjWCZ— Shelley Moore Capito (@Shelley Moore Capito)1512232855.0
When Huffington Post reporters asked Senator Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) about the measure's unpopularity, he insisted it was impossible for legislators to sell tax cuts before they're passed because tax cuts "are generally unpopular," a claim, FiveThirtyEight points out, is historically inaccurate:
Why is support so low? Americans are opposed to the bill because they think it disproportionately benefits the rich. (It likely will.) President Trump’s administration has argued, however, that there were similar complaints about the Reagan tax cut plan of 1981, which preceded an economic boom.
The Reagan plan, though, was far more popular in 1981 than the current Republican plan is now. In a Gallup survey taken in the days after Reagan signed his tax cuts into law on Aug. 13, 1981, 51 percent of Americans were in favor of it. Just 26 percent of Americans were opposed. The other major tax cut of the Reagan administration (signed in 1986) wasn’t nearly as popular, but it was still more popular than the current GOP legislation. A CBS News/New York Times survey conducted in the days after the bill passed Congress found 38 percent in favor and 34 percent opposed.
Indeed, major tax cut plans are usually more popular than unpopular. Heck, even some tax hikes have been more popular than the current GOP bill.
A report from Politico posits that Republicans "are giving taxpayers little time to adjust to sometimes major changes in policy." They expect, for example, to implement the new tax regime on January 1, only days after they hope to push it through Congress.
“The more you read, the more you go, ‘Holy crap, what’s this?'” said Greg Jenner, a former top tax official in George W. Bush’s Treasury Department. “We will be dealing with unintended consequences for months to come because the bill is moving too fast.”