Job Losses from Robots? Bill Gates Weighs In With Novel Approach

Munich, Germany - February 17: Bill Gates at Munich Security Conference on February 17, 2017 in Munich, Germany. (Photo by Michael Gottschalk/Photothek via Getty Images)

[DIGEST: The Seattle Times, Quartz, Business Insider, The Economist, Forbes]

For humans, nothing is certain except death and taxes. Lucky for them, robots needn’t worry about either. That is, unless Bill Gates has his way—then taxes will become a certainty for them, too. (Death they can still avoid.)

In a recent interview with online publication Quartz, Gates expressed his opinion that if robots are going to be taking over a significant part of the workforce, they should be taxed similarly to humans.

The replacement of human labor with automated labor is a growing threat to certain sectors of the American workforce. A 2013 Oxford report found that robots could displace up to half of jobs between 2023 and 2033. A 2015 report out of consulting company McKinsey found that under today’s technology, 45 percent of jobs could be replaced right now.

Gates said that robots, which will likely initially replace jobs in telemarketing, tax preparation, and retail service jobs, should be taxed in order to create space for other jobs where “human empathy and understanding” are key—for instance, teachers and healthcare workers.  

“So if you can take the labor that used to do the thing automation replaces, and financially and training-wise and fulfillment-wise have that person go off and do these other things, then you’re net ahead. But you can’t give up that income tax, because that’s part of how you’ve been funding that level of human workers,” Gates said.

But many economists warn taxing robots is not a good idea. James Bessen, an economist at Boston University’s School of Law, cautioned that computer automation is actually increasing employment in most industries. Accordingly, a tax would slow job growth and limit economic opportunity.

“Investments in robots can make human workers more productive rather than expendable,” mused an unnamed author in The Economist. “Slowing the deployment of robots in health care and herding humans into such jobs might look like a useful way to maintain social stability. But if it means that health-care costs grow rapidly, gobbling up the gain in workers’ incomes, then the victory is Pyrrhic.”

Companies also argue that imposing a tax would hamper innovation. Gates, however, is okay with the prospect that a tax might slow down innovation. “[Y]ou ought to be willing to raise the tax level and even slow down the speed of that adoption [of robotic labor] somewhat to figure out, ‘OK, what about the communities where this has a particularly big impact.’”

He continued, “It is really bad if people overall have more fear about what innovation is going to do than they have enthusiasm. That means they won’t shape it for the positive things it can do.”


Ken Starr, a conservative pundit and frequent Fox News guest, is best known for his dogged attacks to find impeachable offenses by President Bill Clinton during a multi-year investigation into every aspect of the Clinton family's lives.

In the end, Starr found an extramarital affair which was used to impeach Clinton and that Clinton lied under oath about his personal life.

Keep reading...
Siavosh Hosseini/NurPhoto via Getty Images

President Donald Trump's personal attorney Rudy Giuliani is known by some to hurt his client more than help him.

Such was the case on Monday afternoon, after Trump's impeachment defense attorney, Jane Raskin, defended Giuliani on the Senate floor, dismissing the idea that he went to Ukraine to look for dirt on former Vice President Joe Biden.

Keep reading...
Fox News // Fox News

New allegations from former National Security Advisor John Bolton in his upcoming memoir have thrown a wrench into the efforts of President Donald Trump's impeachment defense team to bypass a vote for additional witnesses.

According to Bolton, Trump told him explicitly that he wanted to withhold congressionally approved aid from Ukraine until its President announced investigations into Trump's political rivals.

Keep reading...
JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images // Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call

Congressman Justin Amash (I-MI) left the Republican Party in July of last year after frustration with its enabling of President Donald Trump.

Since then, Amash has publicly taken Trump and others to task for lying, and he sided with Democrats in favor of Trump's impeachment by the House of Representatives.

Amash is at it again after Trump tried to dismiss new allegations by former National Security Advisor John Bolton, who wrote in a manuscript of his upcoming memoir that Trump sought to withhold congressionally approved aid from Ukraine until its President announced investigations into the Bidens.

Keep reading...
Drew Angerer/Getty Images

After three years in office, President Donald Trump's average approval rating has never risen above 50 percent.

While he enjoys a high approval rating among the Republican party, a new hashtag trending on Twitter is highlighting those who were so repulsed by him that they left the party all together.

The hashtag #ILeftTheGOP, apparently started by former Conservative writer Cheri Jacobus, shot to one of the top trends on Twitter.

Keep reading...
STR/NurPhoto via Getty Images // Drew Angerer/Getty Images

Just one day after President Donald Trump's lawyers insisted during his Senate impeachment trial that the President did nothing wrong, reporting from the New York Times made the job of defending Trump even more difficult.

The Times reported on the upcoming memoir from Trump's former National Security Advisor John Bolton, which asserts that President Trump sought to withhold $391 million in congressionally approved aid from Ukraine until its President announced an investigation into his potential 2020 rival, former Vice President Joe Biden.

If true, Bolton's assertion would confirm previous second-hand testimony regarding the existence of a quid pro quo in Trump's dealings with Ukraine.

Keep reading...