These Charts Show Why Donald Trump's Approval Ratings Are Unprecedented, and That's Very Bad News for Republicans

US President Donald Trump speaks during a fundraiser in Sioux Falls, South Dakota on September 7, 2018. (Photo by Nicholas Kamm / AFP) (Photo credit should read NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP/Getty Images)

According to polls from varied sources, the view of the United States economy rarely rated higher than now. Only during the booming tech stock period from 1998 to the beginning of 2001 have polls shown higher numbers regarding the economy.

But another approval number continues to fall pointing to an unusual disconnect.


While people see the economy as strong, the job approval rating for President Donald Trump continues to stay below 50 percent and even dips below 40 percent. A look at poll numbers since 1985 shows a trend of strong economies yielding strong job approval for the President in office.

Poll results for the economy in relation to approval of the President. (Bloomberg)

At the end of August, 2018, favorable views of the economy sat at 62.4 percent. A September 10, 2018 Quinnipiac poll put the number even higher at 70 percent.

But at the end of August, Trump polled an average of only 41 percent for his job approval rating. The same Quinnipiac poll that showed 70 percent approval for the economy only garnered a 38 percent approval rating for the President.

August 8/31/18 polls for economy versus approval of the President. (Bloomberg)

Trump frequently points to the economy as a measure of his success.

While he inherited a recovering economy from President Barack Obama—coming up in both economic indicators and favorable poll numbers from the depths it had dropped to under President George W. Bush—other Presidents maintained a high favorability rating based on an inherited economy as the graph shows.

Bush inherited a strong economy from President Bill Clinton and despite the controversy of his win in the 2000 election—losing the popular vote but winning the electoral vote—his job approval rating only fell slightly.

Obama inherited one of the poorest rated economies since Clinton took over from President George H. W. Bush. But his falling approval numbers recovered as he turned the economy around.

Trump's disconnect is not completely without precedent however. The scandals that plagued the end of the Clinton administration put the President's job approval below the view of the economy. Clinton left office with a job approval at 63 percent, but 77 percent of voters viewed the economy favorably.

That disconnect contributed to Vice President Al Gore's defeat in the electoral vote against Bush. And that precedent should concern Republicans.

Heading into the midterm elections in November, the head of their party sits not at 63 percent with a 77 percent favored economy—a 14 percentage point discrepancy. Trump sits at 38 percent job approval with a 70 percent approval of the economy—a 32 percentage point discrepancy.

Republican candidates need to decide whether to embrace Trump or distance themselves. But if they distance themselves from the man, how do they embrace the economy?

Karlyn Bowman, a polling expert at Washington's conservative American Enterprise Institute, stated:

"There’s a huge disconnect. The economy doesn’t seem to be dominating in a way that it often does in elections."

Trump's appointed Director of the Office of Management and Budget, Mick Mulvaney, advised focusing on the economy and not on Trump in a meeting with Republican backers.

But why the big disconnect? What is different this time?

President Trump tends toward polarization. His speech patterns also deals in absolutes. Superlatives like "best" and "biggest" dominate his tweets and rallies.

Perhaps more than prior Presidents, Trump falls into a definite love him or hate him relationship with voters. When asked if they strongly or somewhat approve or strongly or somewhat disapprove of Trump, poll respondents more often choose strongly over somewhat.

The President's strong supporters believe he can do no wrong regardless of scandals or allegations of impropriety and ongoing investigations. But his detractors are equally unlikely to view anything Trump does as right.

So when Trump tweets about the economy, those who fall on the job disapproval side remain unswayed. The President's Twitter posts about his great economic numbers get met with one name over and over: Obama.

And the detractors come with economic figures and statistics to back their view as well as point out areas of the economy where things continue to falter, like individual wages. Trump's tweets fail to sway voters and may actually hurt more than help.

Midterm elections are set for Tuesday, November 6, 2018. Time for Republicans to turn opinion of the President around dwindles daily.

ABC News

As more information becomes available regarding the virus that's caused a public health crisis in the United States, officials at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have urged Americans in hard-hit areas to begin wearing cloth masks to cover their faces.

Unlike medical professionals, who need N95 masks (of which there is a shortage) when treating virus patients, average Americans can wear makeshift cloth masks that block the saliva droplets through which the virus is spread.

Keep reading... Show less
Tom Brenner/Getty Images // MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images

Given President Donald Trump's propensity for lying and his administration's constant misinformation regarding the current global pandemic, Americans across the country have become selective about which sources they deem as credible in seeking potentially lifesaving information in the face of a national health crisis.

Iowa's Republican governor, Kim Reynolds, is in stark disagreement with most Americans on whom to trust regarding measures designed to curb the virus.

Iowa is one of a few states that still has yet to issue a stay-at-home order to slow the virus's spread. Reynolds has resisted taking the step despite a unanimous recommendation from the Iowa Board of Medicine to do so.

National Institute of Allergies and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) director Dr. Anthony Fauci recently said that all states should institute these orders.

Reynolds's response was...telling.

After calling stay-at-home orders a "divisive issue," the governor said:

"I would say that maybe [Fauci] doesn't have all the information"

Fauci has quickly become one of the most notable figures in the pandemic's response, and one of the few officials in President Donald Trump's virus task force that Americans widely trust to deliver accurate information. He's been an integral part of curbing health crises from the HIV/AIDS epidemic in the United States to Avian Flu to H1N1 and more.

If Fauci doesn't have all the information, then the country is—for lack of a better word—completely screwed.

People were appalled at the governor's defense.





It's safe to say that Fauci has more information and experience in these situations than any governor in the nation—including Reynolds.



The death toll in the United States from the virus recently surpassed 6000.

Information saves lives. Ignorance endangers them.

Win McNamee/Getty Images

In the face of the global pandemic that's killed over 5000 Americans, President Donald Trump is still expressing reluctance to employ federal powers to assist states hardest hit by the virus.

Among the most urgent of obstacles some governors are facing is a shortage of crucial medical equipment—including ventilators—often needed to treat the highly contagious respiratory virus.

Keep reading... Show less
Mark Makela/Getty Images

The respiratory virus that's ballooned into a global pandemic and brought daily life in the United States to a halt has carried another chilling side effect with it.

Because the virus originated in Wuhan, China, anti-Chinese hysteria has sprouted up across the country. These racist flames have only been stoked by President Donald Trump, whose insistence on calling it "Chinese virus" corresponded with an uptick in hate crimes and harassment of Asian Americans across the across the United States, regardless of their country of origin or ancestry.

Keep reading... Show less
Samuel Corum/Getty Images // SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images

Even in the face of a national health crisis that threatens hundreds of thousands of American lives, President Donald Trump has consistently signaled that he's incapable of rising to the urgency of the moment, choosing instead to pick fights with governors over Twitter and to brag about the ratings of his press briefings.

That string of behavior continued with a letter to Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), which read more like one of the President's Twitter screeds than a letter from the President of the United States.

Keep reading... Show less
U.S. Navy

The internet is flooded with messages of support for Navy Captain Brett Crozier, who commands the 5000 person crew of the Roosevelt, an aircraft carrier that was recently forced to dock in Guam.

Crozier sent a letter to the Navy this week begging for additional supplies and resources to aid the 93 people on the Roosevelt who tested positive for the virus that's become a global pandemic, as well as facilities for the additional 1000 people who need to be quarantined.

Keep reading... Show less