While reading a prepared statement from President Donald Trump, White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders announced Wednesday that the President ordered the revocation of the security clearance for a former government official. The announcement that former Trump administration officials now under investigation for a variety of criminal offenses would be long overdue.
This was not that announcement.
I have a unique constitutional responsibility to protect the nation’s classified information, including by controlling access to it. Today, in fulfilling that responsibility, I have decided to revoke the security clearance of John Brennan, former director of the Central Intelligence Agency.”
Instead of publicly revoking the clearances of fired and resigned Trump administration officials like Hope Hicks or Michael Flynn, Trump decided to begin revoking clearances of his political opponents—those critics with expert credentials and federal pedigrees who take exception to the running of the Trump White House.
According to the President’s statement, the action is justified because:
Mr. Brennan’s lying and recent conduct characterized by increasingly frenzied commentary is wholly inconsistent with access to the nation’s most closely held secrets.”
So who is the first target of Trump’s purge?
Brennan spent 25 years with the CIA before establishing and directing the National Counterterrorism Center after 9/11 at the request of President George W. Bush. The White House provided no proof or even hinted that Brennan misused his security clearance at any time.
The lies Trump alludes to are criticisms Brennan publicly made of the President’s policies and lack of security protocols that lead to situations like people without clearances in the Oval Office daily for over a year and secret recordings being made in the Situation Room. Since those are matters of public record, they are not actually lies.
It’s astounding how often you fail to live up to minimum standards of decency, civility, & probity. Seems like you will never understand what it means to be president, nor what it takes to be a good, decent, & honest person. So disheartening, so dangerous for our Nation. https://t.co/eI9HaCec1m
— John O. Brennan (@JohnBrennan) August 14, 2018
Brennan left federal service for a few years after completing his special assignment from Bush, but often consulted on issues at the request of the White House. Then in 2009 Obama asked Brennan to return as a Homeland Security Adviser then in 2013 to head the CIA.
I served 6 Presidents, 3 Rs & 3Ds. I directly supported Clinton, Bush 43, and Obama. While I didn’t agree with all their policy choices, I admired and respected all of them, as they put country above their personal interests. Not so with you, as your self adoration is disgraceful https://t.co/A1brb0HW3V
— John O. Brennan (@JohnBrennan) April 5, 2018
The one-time lowly analyst who worked his way up through the ranks provides a wealth of experience and knowledge on matters of national security and counterterrorism. It is for that reason his clearance was retained by the government after he retired in January 2017.
I had the privilege of working with @JohnBrennan at the White House. I have never met anyone more dedicated to defending our national security than John. He will now be just as vigorous & vigilant in defending American values, including free speech, without a sec clearance.
— Michael McFaul (@McFaul) August 15, 2018
Separated and retired employees that the government chooses to retain clearances for gain no special access however so they pose no inherent risks. They cannot walk into restricted areas or request classified or top-secret documents.
So what benefit did his security clearance have for John Brennan? None, really.
John Brennan doesn’t just call up the CIA and say, “Hey I want to be briefed on ‘this’ or ‘that'”.
The CIA calls Brennan when they need his help and experience in securing our nation.
Trump didn’t attack Brennan today. He attacked the United States of America.
— Brian Krassenstein (@krassenstein) August 15, 2018
The sole purpose of retained clearances is for the benefit of the government. If a retired of separated expert’s help is needed, they can be called on for advice or assistance or in the event of catastrophic events like 9/11, to fill in where mass vacancies of experienced personnel happen too quickly for the government to handle through normal hiring or training.
So why revoke a clearance that only benefits the government? John Brennan himself spoke to that on Twitter.
This action is part of a broader effort by Mr. Trump to suppress freedom of speech & punish critics. It should gravely worry all Americans, including intelligence professionals, about the cost of speaking out.”
My principles are worth far more than clearances. I will not relent.”
This action is part of a broader effort by Mr. Trump to suppress freedom of speech & punish critics. It should gravely worry all Americans, including intelligence professionals, about the cost of speaking out. My principles are worth far more than clearances. I will not relent. https://t.co/TNzOxhP9ux
— John O. Brennan (@JohnBrennan) August 15, 2018
The president also wants to revoke the security clearances of former FBI Director James B. Comey; former CIA Director Michael V. Hayden; former National Security Adviser Susan E. Rice; former Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper Jr.; former FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe; Sally Q. Yates, the former acting attorney general; former FBI officials Lisa Page and Peter Strzok; and Bruce Ohr, a current Justice Department official.
Trump criticized Ohr on Twitter because he knows Christopher Steele, who compiled an as yet substantiated dossier containing damaging, but accurate information about Trump.
Bruce Ohr of the “Justice” Department (can you believe he is still there) is accused of helping disgraced Christopher Steele “find dirt on Trump.” Ohr’s wife, Nelly, was in on the act big time – worked for Fusion GPS on Fake Dossier. @foxandfriends
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) August 14, 2018
Sanders refused to comment on why the list did not include Trump’s former national security adviser Michael Flynn, who pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI or any other Trump official under investigation for misconduct or criminal activity.
The Twittersphere certainly had comments on the issue however.
There are no words that would accurately express my utter contempt for you.That you call yourself a Christian and bear false witness daily is the epitome of hypocrisy
— P Baird (@farandwee) August 15, 2018
In adding John Brennan to his enemies list, Trump demonstrates again how deeply insecure and vindictive he is — two character flaws dangerous in any President.
An enemies list is ugly, undemocratic and un-American. I also believe this action to silence a critic is unlawful. https://t.co/bfOhThIWfq
— Adam Schiff (@RepAdamSchiff) August 15, 2018
If you think revoking Brennan’s clearance as part of a political Enemies List is okay because you got two SCOTUS seats, a tax cut, and some regulatory rollback, maybe you should re-think your principles as an American.
You know who thinks this is awesome? Putin and AQ.
— Tom Nichols (@RadioFreeTom) August 15, 2018
And writer Jamil Smith pointed out that Trump’s description of Brennan sounded a lot more like someone else Trump knows really well.
Trump described @JohnBrennan as guilty of “erratic conduct and behavior” and lacking in “objectivity and credibility.” He wrote that Brennan made “unfounded and outrageous allegations,” has been caught “lying,” and has engaged in “frenzied commentary.” OK. https://t.co/luaZPhYZ2p
— Jamil Smith (@JamilSmith) August 15, 2018
But do not worry. According to Vice President Joe Biden, Brennan will be just fine.
In the time I have known him, John Brennan has never been afraid to speak up and give it to you straight. Revoking his security clearance is an act unbecoming of a President. If you think it will silence John, then you just don’t know the man.
— Joe Biden (@JoeBiden) August 15, 2018