Ed Henry, the chief national correspondent for Fox News, fact-checked weekend ‘Fox & Friends’ host Pete Hegseth on Saturday after Hegseth claimed that former President Barack Obama should not be given credit for the healthy economy.
“Democrats want to talk about health care. They don’t want to talk about immigration. They can’t talk about the economy. I mean Barack Obama is trying to say he rebuilt the economy.”
At which point Henry chimed in:
“You’ve read the numbers, I’m sure. Barack Obama created more jobs in his final 21 months than President [Donald] Trump has created in his first 21. I’m not saying this President inherited it, but would you acknowledge that he was handed a better economy than Barack Obama got?”
You can watch it below:
People were happy to see such a spot on instant fact-check on Fox News:
@edhenry good job reminding, or most likely informing & enlightening your co-host Pete Hegseth; to his dismay, of the facts of the economy & job creation under the current & previous administration. Finally refreshing to hear, while channel surfing & coming upon your news outlet.
— Patrick Fontaine (@pjfontaine0123) November 5, 2018
At last a presenter on FOX news with some decency not to lie
— Nasreen Davidson (@nasdavidson) November 4, 2018
Wow. A foxer telling the truth?
— @carolyn (@lstl5) November 4, 2018
Despite being shut down, however, Hegseth wouldn’t let it go.
“Here’s what I’ll acknowledge,” Hegseth responded. “Four million new jobs, over four million less people on food stamps. To me, that is a reflection of a President that puts business and the private sector ahead of government assistance and bailouts.”
“He was handed a good economy and made it better,” Henry said.
Later, during a discussion with Fox Business host Steve Varney, Henry suggested that Hegseth gets “triggered” whenever he hears anything positive about Obama’s economy.
“When Barack Obama came to office, he was losing 600, 700 thousand jobs a month. We were in financial free-fall, correct?… By the end of his administration, in his final 21 months, he created more jobs than President Trump has created in his first 21 months,” he said.
“Are you saying he started this?” said co-host Katie Pavlich.
“President Trump has done a great job on the economy. Cutting taxes, regulations, it’s roaring. You’re absolutely right,” Henry said. “All I’m saying it wasn’t the table set by Barack Obama? Why can’t Republicans just admit that?”
“It was not set by President Obama. The policies pursued by President Obama were tax, spend, going to debt, and regulate heavily,” Varney replied.
“Hang on, how much debt has President Trump added?” Henry asked, noting that Trump has been “spending money like mad and adding to the debt.”
An analysis by The Joint Committee on Taxation released in November 2017 found that the Republican tax plan would add $1 trillion to the deficit over a decade––even when accounting for economic growth.
A Penn Wharton Budget Model predicts the tax plan would add approximately $1.39 trillion to the deficit, while a Tax Foundation predicts the proposal would add $516 billion to the deficit.
Last year, a troubling report from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) revealed that the plan “gives substantial tax cuts and benefits to Americans earning more than $100,000 a year”––hitting the nation’s poorest citizens particularly hard––and that the legislation would “add an increase in the deficit of $1,414 billion over the next 10 years.”
The administration had yet to release any type of tax analysis, however, and those inside the Treasury’s Office of Tax Policy told reporters that they are not working on any analysis Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin has mentioned. In fact, an economist at the Office of Tax Analysis, who spoke to New York Times reporters on the condition of anonymity, said Treasury had not released a “dynamic” analysis indicating the tax plan will pay for itself with economic growth because one did not exist.
The president counts Fox and Friends among his favorite programs, and in September, he came under fire after he, quoting Fox News contributor Peter Ferrara, claimed that the nation’s economic recovery “got started on Election Day 2016.” Ferrara, an attorney and policy analyst, credited Trump’s “tax cuts and regulation cuts” for the healthy economy.
“The recovery got started on Election Day 2016. It took Trump’s Tax Cuts and Regulation Cuts to get the economy booming. Before that it was the worst and slowest economic recovery since the Great Depression. It took just 6 months for Trump to get to 3%, even though they said…..
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 19, 2018
….it was impossible – and then already it’s over 4%, and I expect it’s going to grow faster and faster. We’re just getting started here.” Peter Ferrara, former advisor to President Reagan. @foxandfriends
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 19, 2018
This claim was quickly shown to be incorrect. Digital strategist John Aravosis pointed out that economy actually grew faster under Trump’s predecessor.
Lie. The economy grew faster under Obama (it hit 3% growth 12 times under O), and the stock market tripled under Obama. Also unemployment plummeted. Think of how bad a job Trump has done if he has to lie about his greatest hits. https://t.co/LQHJkmljsD pic.twitter.com/fFs5SW9kJc
— John Aravosis 🇺🇸 (@aravosis) September 19, 2018
In fact, economists agree Obama essentially handed Trump a thriving economy, a fact many won’t let Trump––who has often taken credit for Obama’s successess––forget.
This is far from the first time Trump––and the White House––has attempted to obfuscate Obama’s legacy.
In August, in a tweet touting U.S. job growth under Trump, the White House accidentally put the strength of the economy into its proper context by amplifying a graph showing 94 months of consecutive job growth, going back to 2011.
When Barack Obama was president.
Since President @realDonaldTrump was elected, there's been outstanding job growth in construction, manufacturing, mining, logging, and other American industries.
See the numbers from the longest monthly job growth streak in U.S. history: https://t.co/H5mop38ygO
— The White House (@WhiteHouse) August 7, 2018
Given what we know about when Obama was president and when Trump entered office, it stands to reason that the current rate of U.S. job growth does not indicate, as the White House suggests, “that the American labor market is thriving under the Trump Administration’s pro-growth policies.”
Although Trump has often claimed that the economy has “never been better,” economists have warned that U.S. job growth is largely the result of government borrowing, and there will be more borrowing as the federal deficit rises because of the president’s tax cuts. This progress, unfortunately, is unlikely to be sustainable after a few quarters. And although the United States is on track to add 2.6 million jobs this year, an Associated Press investigation found that the boom favors Democratic strongholds, not areas which Trump won in 2016.