Legal Abortion in the U.S. Is Safe, It's the Restrictions Being Placed on It That Are Endangering Women's Lives

MANHATTAN, NEW YORK CITY, UNITED STATES - 2017/02/11: Several hundred pro-choice, anti-Trump administration demonstrators gathered in Washington Square park to rally & demand that Planned Parenthood continue to receive federal funding, which the Republican Congress has targeted for defending under the Trump administration. (Photo by Andy Katz/Pacific Press/LightRocket via Getty Images)

Banning abortion does not stop abortion. It just changes where it happens, how it happens, when it happens, and increases the risk of the procedure. A 186-page report by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine unequivocally concludes that modern, legal abortion in the United States is safe and effective. However, states that seek to limit abortion by mandating waiting periods, pre-procedure counseling, or by placing onerous restrictions on facilities that perform the procedure actually succeed not in making the procedure less frequent, but in making it less safe.

"Abortion is safer when it's performed earlier in gestation," said Dr. Hal Lawrence, CEO of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. "And so delaying and making people wait and go through hoops of unnecessary, extra procedures does not improve the safety. And actually by having them delay, can actually worsen the safety."

Within the first 10 weeks, women can take a single dose of the oral medication mifepristone combined with a vaginal suppository of misoprostol, which effectively bring on a miscarriage. The combination can be purchased online and administered at home; however, it’s safer for patients to take under the guidance of a medical professional—if one is available in the patient’s geographic area. The report notes that 17 percent of women had to travel more than 50 miles to obtain an abortion due to the diminishing number of clinics operating in many states.

In 27 states, women are required to first undergo counseling. In 26 states, women must undergo an ultrasound, which adds to the costs. The report also found that the 75 percent of women seeking abortion are low-income, with more than half reporting incomes under the federal poverty level, which means that difficulties in raising funds lead to greater risk and procedures occurring at later stages of development. The report found that 90 percent of abortions are conducted in the first 12 weeks, but a delay in obtaining an early abortion leads to the need for a more intensive procedure that carries a greater risk of complications.

DIY Abortions Make a Comeback Amid Increasing Restrictions

Even more risky: DIY abortions. As more states impose barriers to the procedure, more women are seeking ways to end their pregnancies at home. Others, empowered by alternative medicine and a wish for privacy or fear of clinical experience, make this option their first choice. Before Roe vs. Wade made access to safe abortion legal in the US—and as far back as the earliest recorded history of the pre-modern era—women relied on a variety of self-administered treatments. The first recorded evidence of induced abortion is from the Egyptian Ebers Papyrus in 1550 BC. In British Colonial America, abortion was considered acceptable up until the point of “quickening” and women relied on herbal remedies to bring on a missed period. Today, mail-order drugs and Internet advice are replacing safe clinical treatment for some women.

As states increasing impose restrictions on clinical practice and education about the procedure, and threats against abortion providers continue, an underground home abortion midwifery movement is empowering women to learn procedures to perform on themselves and on others. As one online resource puts it, “we all deserve the right to choose how, where, and with whom we want to have our abortions.”

The Guttmacher Institute recorded 926,200 abortions in 2014, down 12% from 1.06 million in 2011, an achievement that comes from improved access to highly effective contraception such as IUDs or from increased barriers to legal clinical abortion imposed in many states, depending on who you ask. However, this seeming success—for both anti-choice groups that wish to reduce abortion and for pro-choice groups that hope to reduce the need for abortion—may be an illusion.

As Vice President Mike Pence trumpets the coming end to legal abortion, Google searches for DIY abortion have skyrocketed. In 2015, economist Seth Stephens-Davidowitz found more than 700,000 Google searches for self-induced abortion. In 2017, in a span of 32 days, the search was conducted upwards of 200,000 times, with more than two-thirds of searches being conducted in the South or Midwest, where access to legal clinical abortion has been most eroded.

A 2016 study by University of Washington researcher Alison Ojanen-Goldsmith identified 843 people who had used alternative abortion methods, and/or provided underground home abortion services (sometimes called “full spectrum doulas”) to others. The study estimated that each person was involved in anywhere between 10 and 100 home abortions. “That’s huge,” Ojanen-Goldsmith says. “There are potentially thousands of these abortions happening every year.”

In Texas, where onerous legislation is shutting down abortion clinics, abortion drugs carried across the border are widely available not just through the black market, but at flea markets. Raids by police have driven access underground but, as we’ve seen since the days of Prohibition, illegality is just a temporary inconvenience. “If a woman wants to abort, she’s going to abort,” says Lucy Felix, a health educator at the National Latina Institute for Reproductive Health.

According to the World Health Organization, more than 21 million women annually have unsafe abortions worldwide, which account for nearly 13 percent of all maternal deaths.

As usual, it’s women in poverty who suffer the most. “So undocumented women, what can they do?” asked Felix. “They put things in their vagina. I've heard that women are using coat hangers or some are going to Mexico and getting clandestine abortions, where it's dirty, unhygienic.”

In other words, as safe, legal abortion becomes more difficult to obtain in modern America, the methods that brought about Roe vs. Wade in the first place are making a comeback.

CNN video; Samuel Corum/Getty Images

With the world facing a viral pathogen with no vaccine or proven effective treatment, people are understandably on edge.

Hoping to give people a smile or a laugh, lawyer and fiscally conservative Republican—and Donald Trump adversary—George Conway decided to give folks the set up for an old joke with a new twist.

Keep reading... Show less
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Even the most powerful office on the planet requires a level of humility and a willingness to admit when something goes wrong. President Donald Trump didn't get that memo.

Whether it's on Obama, the "fake news media," traitorous Republicans, the impeachment "hoax," or anything within even the most laborious reach, Trump can always find some person or entity on whom to pass the blame.

Keep reading... Show less
Fox Business

After less than a year on the job and with zero White House press briefings to her name, Stephanie Grisham will step down as White House press secretary, returning to her work with First Lady Melania Trump as her Chief of Staff.

Stephanie Grisham is the third White House Press Secretary to step down during the administration of President Donald Trump.

Keep reading... Show less
Shannon Finney/Getty Images

Across the country, states have instituted stay-at-home orders in an effort to curb the spread of the highly contagious virus that's upended daily life in the United States.

Late last month, Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers issued one of these orders, urging his constituents to only leave their houses for necessary errands, such as getting groceries or filling prescriptions.

There's just one problem: Wisconsin's elections are scheduled for April 7. In addition to the Presidential primaries, Wisconsinites will vote for judicial positions, school board seats, and thousands of other offices.

The Democratic and Republican National Committees took the case to the Supreme Court, with Democrats arguing that the deadline for mailing absentee ballots should be extended by a week, to April 13, in order to facilitate voting from home.

With a Wisconsin Supreme Court Seat up for grabs on Tuesday, Republicans predictably made the case for why as few people as possible should be permitted to vote. It was a continuation of Wisconsin GOP efforts to suppress the vote, which included rejecting a demand from Governor Evers to automatically mail an absentee ballot to every resident.

The Republican majority in United States Supreme Court sided with the RNC and the election in Wisconsin will carry on as scheduled. This is despite Wisconsin being unprepared for the surge in absentee ballot requests, which leapt from a typical 250,000 to over 1.2 million in reaction to the virus. Thousands of these voters won't even receive these ballots until after the election, thereby preventing them from exercising their right to vote.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote a blistering dissent to the majority's decision, saying:

"Either [voters] will have to brave the polls, endangering their own and others' safety. Or they will lose their right to vote, through no fault of their own. That is a matter of utmost importance — to the constitutional rights of Wisconsin's citizens, the integrity of the State's election process, and in this most extraordinary time, the health of the Nation."

She was flabbergasted that her more conservative colleagues didn't think a global pandemic and national crisis was enough to justify emergency policies ensuring Wisconsinites their right to vote:

"The Court's suggestion that the current situation is not 'substantially different' from 'an ordinary
election' boggles the mind...Now, under this Court's order, tens of thousands of absentee voters, unlikely to receive their ballots in time to cast them, will be left quite literally without a vote."

A majority of the Supreme Court may not have agreed with Ginsburg, but the court of public opinion was fully on her side.

The Republican efforts indicated to some that the party cares more about maintaining control than preserving lives.

Large crowds are already gathering in Wisconsin to vote.

In a bit of devastating irony, the Supreme Court voted remotely when making its decision.

For more information about the tried and true tactic of GOP voter suppression, check out Uncounted, available here.

JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images

Despite numerous cautions from medical experts—including those on his staff—President Donald Trump continues to tout hydroxychloroquine as a promising treatment for the virus that's brought daily life in the United States to a standstill.

The drug has undergone no clinical trials to scientifically test its efficacy on the virus, and the evidence on its behalf is anecdotal at best. One Fox News guest, Access Health International Chairman William Haseltine, called it a "quack cure."

Keep reading... Show less
Catherine Nance / Echoes Wire/Barcroft Media via Getty Images

President Donald Trump's personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, is back in the public eye after keeping a relatively low profile following the impeachment trial against his client.

Keep reading... Show less