anticipates the project will encourage people to travel to view the curious attraction of an iceberg off the Arabian Gulf coast.
Critics Oppose Towing the Iceberg
The concept of the towed iceberg as a by-product tourist destination adds more fuel to the assertion of Professor Martin Siegert—co-director of the Grantham Institute for climate change and the environment at Imperial College London—who called the entire plan a “stunt.”
For instance, Siegert explained that icebergs typically do not exist far north of Antarctica because of the Southern Ocean’s turbulent seas and strong polar current. “Breaking through this would be a major feat, and would depend on favorable conditions that are not guaranteed.” He added that the iceberg would likely melt, break apart, or get caught in undercurrents during the towing process.
Such a venture, which remains in the early planning stages, still requires approval from several governmental bodies. First, the UAE government will need to authorize the project, as will Australia and other governments of nations whose ecosystems will be affected by the large ship dragging the iceberg across their ecosystems. In fact, global treaties that subject Antarctica to environmental regulations could also affect the project.
Likewise, environmentalists such as Charlotte Streck—director of the consultants firm Climate Focus—have been also been critical of the idea. Streck told the AP the project ran “counter to all ideas of climate change adaptation,” and called it “exceptionally futile” and “expensive.” Robert Brears, of the climate think tank Mitidaption, estimates the upfront expenditure will cost at least $500 million.
Meanwhile, Al-Shehi counters that the process is less expensive than desalinization, which currently provides most of the Gulf region’s water, and emphasized the financial benefits from his predicted weather changes and increased tourism. To the National Advisor Bureau, these benefits are worth the risks outlined by their critics.
According to Al-Shehi, “The icebergs are just floating in the Indian Ocean. They are up for grabs to whoever can take them.”